Raising the hands in Salah – another reply to Zubair Ali Za’i

08 Jan, 2014

This is another work by Faysal Khan (of Pakistan) in defence of the evidences used to substantiate the practice of non-raf’ul yadayn (not raising the hands) in Salah (namaz) after the initial Takbir of Salah as advocated by the Hanafi and Maliki schools of Sunni Islamic Law. In doing so it is a direct reply to the late  Zubair Ali Za’i (d. 2013) of Pakistan who attempted to weaken all such proofs used by the named schools of Law.   The work is in Urdu with the key proofs also in Arabic.  Another work on this matter by the same author was uploaded here

The work by Zubair Ali Zai seems to have been used by some of his UK based followers (Abu Khuzaima and Abu Hibban) who published it under the following cover by abridging it in the English language:

scan-kitaab-raf-ul-yadain
It has been stated in our work on establishing 20 Rak’ats of Taraweeh as a response to the last two named individuals:

Indeed, these two compilers (Abu Khuzaimah/Abu Hibban) have also put out a short book in reply to most of the proofs used by the Kufan scholars and the position of the Hanafi and most of the Maliki school on not raising the hands (raf’ul yadayn) in Salah after the first Takbir, and they also dismissed al-Zaylai’s own authentication of some non-raful yadayn narrations from his Nasb al Ra’ya as a consequence. What is bewildering to note is that they released this book under one pseudonym of “Abu Asaakir al-Araaqee”!! Despite it being known that it was compiled by two individuals!

—————————————————————————————————————————————–

DISCLAIMER: To the best of our knowledge, it seems as if Faysal Khan is an independent researcher and not a scholar who has graduated from any Islamic Institute of learning from the subcontinent such as a Dar al-‘Ulum. His work has been uploaded as it was written in an academic manner, and he has utilised a number of good arguments and points within it.

Those who wish to read a summary of some of the well known proofs on this matter in English may read the following work for now.  A lengthier work in English is in the pipeline from the pen of Dr. Abul Hasan Hussain Ahmed.

  Download link for English work

Download link for the reply to Zubair Ali Za’i

Read online:

 

Related Posts

Leave a reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.